Geoffrey was murdered into the a biking collision in 1186 and you may Constance hitched (2) Ranulph de Blundeville, cuatro th Earl of Chester, towards the step three rd February 1188, within the a married relationship set-up of the King Henry eleven. That it relationship deteriorated and you may Ranulph imprisoned Constance when you look at the 1196. Rebellions were sparked around the Brittany on the and you can Ranulph put out their within the 1198. Back to Brittany, Constance got their relationships annulled and soon after in 1198, she got Guy de- Trips due to the fact their unique ‘second’ partner.
Constance died aged 40, (possibly out-of leprosy, perhaps following childbirth to dual girls) toward 5 th September 1201 on Nantes
The theory one to Constance got an event with John after the loss of Geoffrey and before John’s wedding in order to Isabella from Gloucester inside the 1189, and that she was mother so you’re able to Joanna is really contentious and you can possess provoked far talk inside genealogical circles.
Because of the just which have sex with John, let-alone influence him a baby, Constance would have oriented a first-degree dating off affinity with all of John’s sisters –– plus John’s aunt Geoffrey
One feedback away from a beneficial genealogist says you to ‘the fresh journal ‘The newest Plantagenet Connection’ has actually authored an ahnentafel off Age Plantagenet, partner away from Henry V11, which gives Joanna’s mother’s term since Constance (maybe misnamed Clemence?), Duchess off Brittany. This is the Constance who was John’s sis-in-rules! Considering the really-known animosity anywhere between John and you can Constance along with her own attempts to push their particular child Arthur’s hobbies so far as the fresh new throne of England are concerned (therefore all the know the way disastrously that proved!), I truly find the advised matchmaking a tiny tough to ingest. This new Constance you to definitely record illustrates doesn’t strike me as the into just who John could easily coerce with the sleep.’
‘ A concept who does identify Joanna’s mom given that Constance doesn’t make up an incredibly critical point in cannon law. That would mean that some shadow of the matter need to certainly have come as a result of all of us, if this on it the new request for it, new deliberations, or even the actual dispensation alone. In so far as i am alert, nothing of one’s kind is available.’
My own opinion for what it is value, is that had Constance become the mother from Joanna she’d certainly keeps put their own upwards inside her house and her name could well be as well labeled as Constance’s most other people by Geoffrey (Eleanor, Reasonable Maid regarding Brittany, Matilda/Maud regarding Brittany and you may Arthur).
Agatha came into this world about 1168 in Chartley Castle, Staffordshire. It’s notorious that she try a mistress off John and many household members woods bring their particular, even in the event unmarried, since mother off Joanna. Really genealogists but not believe that it is just supposition that she is Joanna’s mother given that no research or facts exist to show that it.
Even though this wasn’t a consanguineous matchmaking however, certainly attraction, one first-knowledge relationship might have rendered relationships between Constance and you will any of John’s brothers hopeless versus a dispensation –– which given the party’s review might have must come from the fresh new pope themselves
One supply appear to offered is Sir William Dugdale, regarding the Baronage out-of England (1675-6). According to him their source to be Dr David Howell’s ‘Reputation of Wales’ (1584). Powell’s work is an enlarged edition away from H Lloyd’s interpretation away from ‘The Historie of Cambria’ because of the 12 th century Saint Caradoc out of Llancarfan. An alternative resource, ‘Magna Carta Barons’ of the Charles Browning, copyright laws 1969 including names Agatha de- Ferrers, daughter of Robert de- Ferrers, next Earl regarding derby, because the Joanna’s mommy.
Even when she can not be completely overlooked since a candidate to possess mother off Joanna, certainly there would be specific trace out-of their own for the a good chronicle or other historic reference, in the event the she had indeed become mom of your own wife off the latest Prince regarding North Wales.